Richmond Council vs Gays & Lesbians
     
   

Tuesday, 20 April 2004 7:00 pm, Council

Venue:    COUNCIL CHAMBER, YORK HOUSE, TWICKENHAM
 
Contact:    Mary Collins, Democratic Services Manager
Tel: 020 8891 7860, m.collins@richmond.gov.uk
 
1.  MINUTES   

To approve as a correct record the Minutes of the Council held on 2 March 2004 TO FOLLOW.

 
2.  DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST   

Members are asked to declare any interests in matters for consideration at the meeting.

 
3.  PETITIONS   

To receive Petitions in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 2.1 (iv).

 
4.  PUBLIC QUESTIONS   
 
4a.  Mr Cass Mann has given notice to ask the Leader and Cabinet Member for Combating Crime:   

“Writing to the Richmond & Twickenham Times as a Richmond Councillor on 12 March, using the Council's email pathway and York House geographical address, Cllr Cranfield-Adams denounced "some from the gay community" in Richmond for their "vindictiveness and spite" in seeking to have Cllr Dance "hung, drawn and quartered". As his claims are demonstrably untrue and unjustified, he is in clear breach of Council's Members' Code of Conduct in the following sections under Part 1, General Provisions: (a) Scope - 1.02 a, b, c; (b) General Obligations - 2.02 a, b, c; (c) Bringing the Authority into Disrepute - 4.01.

 

Will the Leader confirm that these allegations, issued as an official Council communication, are entirely without foundation or merit and that they are withdrawn immediately by Council (as, otherwise, Council are party to and implicated in his abuse of the local gay community) and if this simple and direct remedial action will not be undertaken, could evidence be made public for these allegations being justified?”

 
4b.  Mr Cass Mann has given notice to ask the Leader and Cabinet Member for Combating Crime:   

“Once again, writing as a Richmond Councillor on 9 March to the editor of Online Communities, using the Council's email pathway, Cllr Cranfield-Adams threatened the Online Communities website with "the removal of your entire website" for having published a cartoon depicting several Councillors, including himself, as members of the Village People. This, he claimed, defamed the Councillors as "the style of (the cartoon and Village People) had/has strong homosexual overtones".

 

As Cllr Cranfield-Adams was the only Councillor to complain, and the only Councillor to have previously publicly declared himself homosexual, what disciplinary action does the Council now intend to take as his legal threat, issued as an official Council communication, to close down the borough's only independent community website, has brought the Council into disrepute and in this he is in clear breach of the Council's Members' Code of Conduct in precisely the same categories and sections as in Question 1? The legal threat he issued as a matter of Council business is an unprecedented blow to democracy in the borough, as the Council must surely acknowledge.

 
4c.  Mr Cass Mann has given notice to ask the Leader and Cabinet Member for Combating Crime:   

“On 23 March, the Cabinet recommended the adoption of the Equality and Diversity Policy and Strategy and, in response to my representations to that Cabinet meeting, I was advised by the Chief Executive that Council disciplinary procedures for breaches and contraventions of said document were too voluminous to incorporate into it but were available elsewhere.

 

Could the Leader now advise me how the several breaches and contraventions of said document by Cllr Cranfield-Adams as itemised in the Questions 1 and 2 will be dealt with and refer me to the disciplinary procedures involved, the breaches and contraventions being of the following sections:

Our Commitments:

 

We will promote...fair treatment for all our communities.

We will work with specific groups of people who are hard to reach...

We will particularly work with those groups who experience marginalisation, disadvantage and discrimination... 

We will ensure that all Members...are clear about their roles and responsibilities under equalities legislation and Council policy...

 

Roles and Responsibilities for Implementation, Monitoring and Review:

 

Elected members will fulfil their statutory responsibilities under equalities legislation and aim to promote good community relations in all their work, particularly in their community leadership role.

 

Key Strategic Objectives:

 

To prevent unlawful discrimination and institutional discrimination.

To promote good relations between all sections of our diverse communities?”

 
5.  MEMBERS' QUESTIONS   

To receive questions from Members in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 11.2, of which due notice has been given.

 

To follow

 
6.  WARD CONCERNS   
 
6a.  Councillor Hoskinson has given notice to raise the following Ward Concern:   

Purpose Built Town Houses, Hampton North Ward.

 
6b.  Councillor Head has given notice to raise the following Ward Concern:   

Radnor Gardens, South Twickenham Ward.

 
 
7.  REPORTS OF THE EXECUTIVE AND COMMITTEES PDF 66 K    

Attached

 
 
8.  REPORTS OF OVERVIEW AND SCRUTINY COMMITTEES   

None

 
9.  REPORTS ON JOINT ARRANGEMENTS AND EXTERNAL ORGANISATIONS   

None

 
10.  REPORTS OF THE HEAD OF PAID SERVICE   
 
10a.  AMENDMENTS TO THE CONSTITUTION PDF 72 K    

Attached

 
11.  EXECUTIVE DECISIONS TAKEN AS A MATTER OF URGENCY   

None.

 
12.  ANNOUNCEMENTS   

To receive any announcements from the Mayor, Leader, Members of the Cabinet or the Head of Paid Service.

 
13.  NOTICES OF MOTION   

None.